| |
WXXX - Narrative Report Excerpt
BasicFACTS™ is an assessment based report produced for this
public television station. FACTS stands for Financial Analysis and
Critical Thinking Scenarios. The various FACTS™ reports, including
BasicFACTS™, FutureFACTS™, CashFACTS™, and ImpactFACTS™,
are designed to provide an objective, data-based review of the
station’s financial health, and to support executive decision
making. It is intended for internal management use.
BasicFACTS™ uses three principal data sources. They include annual audit
reports from the station’s independent auditing firm, SABS Benchmarking reports,
station budgets and other financial management reports. In addition to this
information, interviews with senior management are conducted to create a
context and frame of reference for the station’s overall position. Finally, an
analysis of strategic alignment is completed through a community assessment to
provide an approximate indicator of effectiveness in delivery of mission and
community service.
It is important to remember that every station, like every community, is different.
Each operation must be viewed and understood within its unique environment.
BasicFACTS™ is designed as a management tool to attempt to create this
understanding so that station resources can be leveraged to their maximum
return in terms of mission.
Table of Contents: |
| Overview |
3 |
| Narrative |
5 |
| Strengths |
5 |
| Opportunities |
5 |
| Risks |
6 |
| Short-term Outlook |
7 |
| Long-term Outlook |
7 |
| Financial Analysis |
8 |
| Audited Financials |
8 |
| SABS Report |
14 |
| Budget Variance Report |
17 |
| Community Needs Assessment |
20 |
Short-Term Outlook for WXXX:
WXXX’s short term outlook is characterized by the staff reductions that have already taken place and the
ongoing efforts to build its revenue streams. In the near-term, the station will begin the public phase of its
capital campaign. Making efforts to align itself to community needs will strengthen the power of the station’s
appeal. Management should look for mechanisms to make the community assessment happen as
quickly as possible. Meanwhile, the station should take the appropriate steps to creating its endowment.
Through the generosity of a local benefactor, the station also purchased the unoccupied building next
door. It should hold the property and postpone any plans to utilize the property that would require an
investment of dollars during the current fiscal year.
Overall, the short-term outlook is reasonably strong, although not without risk. It will be imperative that
the current management team operate in a consensus manner, and that the Station Manager and Chief
Financial Officer remain the principal architects of the overall financial recovery and operational realignments.
Long-Term Outlook for WXXX:
WXXX’s outlook in the long-term is actually quite positive, assuming the risks that have been described in
this report can be avoided. The station has already experienced the type of difficulties on the horizon for
many public television stations in the coming years, and has taken the appropriate and difficult steps to
adjust itself accordingly. The single largest factor in determining the long-term success of the station will
be its ability to focus on its strategic alignment and continuously ask the question of the community of
how it can best serve the local population. WXXX has navigated difficult waters, and its management
should be well positioned to move into the longer-term future.
Through the generosity of a local benefactor, the station also purchased the unoccupied building next
door. It should hold the property and postpone any plans to utilize the property that would require an
investment of dollars during the current fiscal year.
Review of Audited Financials—Excerpt
Are the station’s
revenues
going up
or down? In
this case,
revenue
growth lagged
the growth in
expenses until
2001. If expenses exceed revenues
consistently, the station will eventually
deplete its reserves. In 2000 the station
essentially operated at breakeven,
and since then has experienced
the windfall of Channel 00’s sale.
However, the overall expense structure
has not been significantly re-
Operating cash flow shows how much
WXXX is generating through its core
activities, and net income is the difference
between total revenues and total expenses.
In 1999 the station made a significant
purchase of equipment that reduced
its operating cash flow to nearly zero.
The graph shows that net income is increasing
more rapidly than operating cash
flow, suggesting a potential future problem
with working capital.
2003 Budget Variance Report For the 4 Months Ended 10/31/02—Excerpt
Overall expenses to date are in line
with the budget; however, individual
line items are, in some cases, significantly
overspent. They include travel,
mail, and professional services, which
are largely discretionary items and
spending should be adjusted accordingly.
In particular the travel budget
overspending is disturbing and should
be thoroughly understood and the
appropriate measures taken. The
lease line is also problematic, as
spending through October has already
reached 73% of the annual budget. Is
this run rate on lease expected to
continue throughout the year? If so,
there will be a $25,000 overrun on
this line.
While the budgetary analysis indicates
that with the exception of the four expense categories mentioned above, appropriate overall financial management is present,
cash flow management remains a real challenge and problem for the station. Management has already made significant staff cuts,
and has proposed a management wage cut of 5%. These issues put the bequest income at risk for being utilized to bridge cash
flow. Management is aware of this potential but restricting the funds to an endowment is the only sure mechanism for safeguarding
this windfall as an income producing asset.
Basic FACTS™ for WXXX 4 Community Needs and Service Assessment—Excerpt
The BasicFACTS™ report uses an
analysis and assessment of the station’s
financial and operating information
in order to understand how
it is performing and what areas may
be important in the short– and longterm
future. However, it is most
important to understand this performance
from the perspective of
the needs of the communities the
station serves and its stated mission.
In order to provide that perspective,
BasicFACTS™ uses the following
process:
- During the initial station interview
with General Manager, Station
Manager and CFO, the following key questions are asked of each manager: 1) What are the top five needs or problems of
the community that makes up your viewing area; 2) what, in your opinion, is the priority of those needs or problems?; and,
3) how would you rate the station’s understanding of the community needs?, 4) how effectively is the station addressing
the community’s needs, and 5) how does the community see the station addressing these needs?
- Interviews are conducted with key representatives from each of the following community entities or organizations:
| Local/county governments |
Higher education |
Economic development board/office |
| Bank/financial institution economist |
Local newspapers |
Regional non-profit board or association of non-profits |
| Local hospital administration |
|
|
- During these interviews, the same five questions are asked
- The responses to these questions are reviewed for consistency across the sample
- The responses are reviewed for consistency with the station perspective
- Matches and disconnects are evaluated
Conclusion:
There is a certain amount of disconnect
between the community and board members.
There is even greater disagreement between the
community perception of WXXX’s effectiveness in
dealing with these issues and the station’s perception.
The community feels that the station understands
what the needs are and simply is not addressing it as
well as it could. Most of the participants in the survey
could identify something they had seen or heard
about on the station that addressed one or more of
the issues. However, the difference in the issues of
concern identified by the community and those identified
by the station would indicate that WXXX does
not fully understand the concerns. Some community
respondents also offered an understanding that the
station couldn’t address all needs because of budgetary
restrictions and problems. WXXX is working hard to serve the community, but unless all parties are in agreement as to
how the community needs to be served, it is an exercise in futility.
Clearly, the station and board need to work in greater concert with the community in addressing the needs expressed as most
problematic and then work to make sure that the station promotes the programs addressing these problems in an effective,
efficient way.
|
|